The card show season has slowed down and I can now update the blog on Friday evenings. This edition ended up being an early Saturday release but welcome anyway and here we go…
Toronto Sports Card Expo
The twice a year show in Toronto is known for hockey cards. The show is billed as the largest hockey card show in North America.
I think they are selling the show short. Of course it is hockey heavy, it’s Canada. But there is more than hockey to be found at the show. Vintage and pre-war baseball, for example, has a nice showing at the show with a nice mix of Canadian and US dealers selling everything from autos to wax and even beef jerky. That guy rocks, by the way.
The May Expo show was the third appearance for Beckett since we started setting up again after a 10 year absence. The decade away from the Great White North was in part due to logistics of traveling to another country. There were plenty of shows in the US for us already and that made it easy to talk ourselves out of doing a show in Canada. We also setup and slabbed cards on-site at the Toronto Expo 10 years ago. BGS only slabs on-site at the National now and offer our on-site services of Raw Card Review and Graded Card Review at all other shows. That means we can take a tenth of the staff and a truck less of equipment to smaller shows making the Toronto show much more do-able.
The May show suffered from perfect weather. It was blue sky and 70 degrees (20 for you Canadians). Sounds great, and it is but not when it isn’t the norm for the area and you have a card show. The casual collector may opt for being outside with the family instead of going to a card show inside a windowless building all day. Who can blame them?
Just like the previous two shows, this show did not disappoint for us. Grading had a great turnout despite the thinner than usual crowd.
I thought we graded all the Gretzky RCs already but I had the privilege of grading more! Surprisingly, out of all the Gretzky cards, I only saw one fake which is a much lower percentage than back at the home office.
I wanted to get a Patrick Roy autograph but time is always scarce for the grading team. Roy was setup directly across from the Beckett booth. The line to get his autograph was very long and the photo op line was as well. Surprising to me since an auto set you back $180.00. I didn’t think I was going to get the auto but I did get to get a signed 8×10 with the help of another Becketteer. (Thanks Bill.)
The former baseball players like Fergie Jenkins and Goose Gossage were staying at our hotel but the long days grading left me too tired to even talk to those guys.
All in all, a great show again for us and nearly no problems.
Is the Toronto show for you? If you are a Canadian, it’s a no-brainer. It is a fun show where the card manufacturers are there giving away stuff and an awesome selection of dealers.
If you are from the US, you should try the show at least once. The cost to go can be reasonable if you use sites like Priceline or if you are close enough to drive. Remember, you must have a valid passport in order to go. There is also customs to deal with if you are taking cards and other stuff to sell at the show. I also recommend going to your local bank and ordering some Canadian currency before you go. It will be cheaper and it is good to have some on hand for deals where US won’t buy it. You don’t have to get a lot to get started. Definitely don’t get more than you think you will spend at the show. Your local US bank probably won’t take coinage when you come back. Mine won’t. Every time I do the show, I end up buying junk at the airport trying to use up my Loonies and Toonies (One and two dollar coins). I still end up with coins at home. I think there is an ashtray that is holding 7 or 8 dollars Canadian on my desk right now.
Glue on the back of a card
I posted a picture of the back of a 1954 Bowman card on Twitter earlier this week. The card was damaged from glue and the remnants of paper from an album. Some of the surface was pulled away. I asked how bad is the grade of a card with glue on the back and can it be removed?
Let’s start with how bad glue is when talking about the grade of a card. If there is glue residue that is light, a card can be in the VG range provided the stain is light. If there is glue that has discolored and stained the stock or there is evidence of removal from an album such as paper stuck to the glue, the grade is going to be in the 1.5 to 2 range at best. Missing surface is serious damage and will put the card in the poor or 1 grade range.
What if you have a card that is either still glued to the album or is removed and only has glue residue on the back? Do you try to remove the card from the album or the glue from the card surface?
The short answer is maybe.
The decision to attempt to remove a card should be based on an educated guess as to what type of glue was used and the type of card stock. A T206 glued to what appears to be a contemporary album is a good candidate for attempting to remove the card via means like soaking. The stock of the card will most likely withstand a proper and careful soaking and the glue will most likely be a water soluble paste. Many pre-war cards can take a soaking if done properly. Newer cards cannot.
When I was in junior high, I had a beat up W516 Walter Johnson strip card I had bought at a local motel card show. It had rounded corners and was a dark grey from years of being handled.
We traded cards at school and I had that card in a top loader in my back pocket. I also had a 1975 Topps Gary Carter rookie card in a top loader in the same pocket. I forgot about the cards when I got home. The jeans were washed the next day with the cards in the back pocket. My mother found them and handed them to me. The carter was first and I could see it was a goner. I removed the card from the top loader and most of the surface stayed with the plastic. The card was a total loss. Stupid me.
I hesitated before looking at the Johnson. This was BE (before eBay) so replacing that card was not going to be easy. I looked at the card and I was shocked. It looked brand new. I took it out of the top loader and the card was as clean as the day it was printed. It had been perfectly laundered! It still had completely rounded corners but the stock looked fake. It was clean and bright and the ink colors popped. I couldn’t believe what I was looking at. A card just barely older than me was destroyed while a card from the year my great grandfather could drink not only survived but it was clean!
How can you be sure the card you have can be soaked? Find a common card from the same set and test it. A cheap common from the set won’t break your heart when you screw it up. Those 10 beautiful cards on an album page that are now in pieces after a bad soaking will break your heart.
Is soaking altering the card? Some say no while others argue anything done to a card is an alteration. My stance is if you are not adding to or taking away from an original card, it is not altering. If you are using water to remove a foreign substance from a card, you aren’t altering or changing the card. Trim an edge? Altering. Erase print or dirt? Altering. Using a chemical to change the appearance of a card? Altering. Rebuilding a missing corner? Altering. Soaking a card in water to remove glue that was added to a card? Not altering in my opinion.
Soaking isn’t quite as simple as I have made it sound but it can be done using only water. I do not want to make this a primer on how to soak cards but I do want to let collectors know that it can be done and some of the precautions to take before attempting such a job.
A photograph or a postcard with a real photo should never be soaked. I have an album that belonged to a player who played for Philly in the 1930s. There are beautiful single player photos in the album that are signed that look like cards. I would love to soak these out but I know I can’t without damaging them. The album was crumbling so I did cut the pages down to around each photo leaving the paper on the backs of the photos. That is how they will most likely stay.
Not only will the photos not take water but the fountain pen signatures will run off the surfaces. They are done in that beautiful blue/black ink like Parker Quink that looks so good. Still bold. I would probably cry if I ruined those autographs.
I have had luck with cards into the 1950s. New cards seem to be too risky. No matter the card, there are risks but modern cards are for sure high risk.
Experimenting can be fun. The first cards I ever tried soaking was a complete set of 1960s Cuban revolution cards pasted in a crumbling album. The cards came out perfect but only after hours of work and a great deal of sweat and stress. I messed up only one card. I was really lucky for being my first time. It was an experiment and I knew I may end up ruining the entire set.
The two worlds of collectibles
Today is my grandfather’s birthday and I gave him a call giving my wishes. As always, we converse about a number of topics. One topic we have in common is antiques and collectibles. Now, this is a man with 60-plus years experience in antiques and he was one of my collectibles mentors.
He recently opened a booth at an antique store local to him. It has been a few years since he has had a booth anywhere selling or buying. He specializes in what I call “real antiques.” What the hell is a “real antique?” I can’t come up with a great sounding definition but let’s say it is everything else besides cards, comics, toys and coins for example. He deals with things like furniture and barber chairs and tools and kitchen items. He’s done advertising and early 20th century. It’s really hard to list the items. It’s really more like a category. I think of it as the show American Pickers. They deal in pretty much everything old, except of collectibles like what I deal in.
What I deal in I can list. Items like trading cards, coins, comics, comic art, fountain pens and toys. That is pretty easy to describe.
We talked about trends and he mentioned the show American Pickers. He said people are buying everything that’s rusted. The rustier the better my grandfather said. That is when it hit me; I come from a different world than he does.
My world has three words that describe the items I am into. Those words are CONDITION, CONDITION, CONDITION. Condition is everything. You have a card that is mint? That’s great but I’m looking for Gem Mint and it needs to be professionally graded. That silver dollar is MS-69? That’s almost perfect. I will have to upgrade to MS-70 when I can.
If I have a comic with a chipped off corner, that will bug the crap out of me until I sell it. Off-centered card? Forget it. It better be a pre-war card if it isn’t near mint or better.
His world doesn’t care about condition. I can’t believe I even said that. Who doesn’t care about condition?
So he is telling me the rustier the better. Who is telling him that? I see that show and those guys are pulling out a bicycle that is buried in a toothless mans front yard. I am thinking what a piece of crap; you got any baseball cards inside where it’s dry?
The Picker guys are dry humping each other trying be the one to buy this hunk of junk.
Let’s go hit eBay and find one of those that still looks like an actual bike.
But I am told by my grandfather that rust is in. Rust sells.
I have spent my entire adult life scrutinizing the physical condition of pieces of cardboard through a loupe. To think that there are people out there that collect “collectibles” that would rather have something run over by a truck just doesn’t compute in my head. But I think I’m starting to get that now. I now realize there are two different worlds of collectors. One group is all about condition and the other that is wrong.
No, the other group isn’t wrong. They want old. They want their item to look the part. They do not care about perfect condition. They want something that has lived. Someone from the rust group might say If I’m hanging a ‘47 Edsel bumper over my fireplace, I want it to look like it’s been living in hell for 70 years. I don’t want people to see a repro, I want them to see the real deal, decomposition and all.
Understanding the difference in the two groups of collectors helps me when I am out buying stuff. I think I can appreciate the beauty in an antique that has stood the test of time and it looks it. That there is beauty in the journey and a piece that looks authentic can takes us back to a place when times were better. That there is something to a barber chair pulled from a trash heap that still has the scars of the many feet that rubbed the foot rest. The worn out seat that held so many first haircuts. The rust that says I stood as a monument against the passage of time.
Maybe the beauty is in the journey, not the preservation of the object.
Nah, it’s still junk. I’ll hold out for Near-Mint.
Signed copies now available!
